Skip to main content
← Crusher Wear Parts Engineering Guides Case Studies

How to Compare Crusher Wear Cost per Tonne

Published: Last updated:

Cost per tonne is useful only when the baseline, part identity, operating window, mass loss and downtime assumptions are recorded consistently.

Redacted limestone crusher hammer worksheet used to explain cost-per-tonne comparison

Calculate crusher wear parts cost per tonne by dividing each set’s net campaign cost by the verified metric tonnes processed in that campaign. Use the quote comparison worksheet to put both offers on the same cost and production basis and calculate the tonnes the candidate needs to match the baseline cost per tonne.

Define the campaign before calculating anything

Set the start and end dates first. The two campaigns can run on different dates. Within each campaign, use the same start date and cut-off for cost and tonnage. Record the following details.

  • machine, line and crusher position;
  • installed part numbers and material specification;
  • number of parts installed and number measured;
  • installation and removal dates;
  • new and removed weights, where practical;
  • processed tonnes from an agreed production record;
  • operating hours and stoppages;
  • feed, setting and throughput changes;
  • abnormal events or partial replacements;
  • delivered part cost and the currency basis.

If parts were rotated, reversed or replaced individually during the period, record those events. A calculation that assumes one unchanged set will otherwise assign production to the wrong component mass.

Calculate mass wear rate on a stated basis

For a set of measured parts:

Total mass loss (kg) = sum of new mass minus removed mass for each measured part

Mass wear rate (g/t) = total mass loss (kg) × 1,000 ÷ verified production (t)

Example: if the measured set loses 2,000 kg during a period that processes 500,000 t, the recorded mass wear rate is 4 g/t. This is a calculation example, not a performance benchmark. A different crusher, feed, part set or measurement scope should not be judged against it without context.

State whether the result represents every installed part or only a sample. If only some parts were weighed, do not scale the result to the full set unless the sampling method and wear distribution justify it.

Calculate component cost per tonne consistently

At its simplest:

Component cost per tonne = delivered component cost consumed in the campaign ÷ verified production

Use the same cost basis for every candidate. Decide whether “delivered component cost” includes freight, duty, insurance and local handling. Do not compare an ex-works price for one supplier with a delivered price for another.

When only part of a set is consumed, define how the remaining value is treated. The cleanest comparison usually closes when the measured set reaches an agreed removal point. If a campaign is still running, label the calculation as interim.

Add the costs that purchase price misses

Component cost per tonne is useful, but total operating impact can include:

  • planned and unplanned change-out labour;
  • crane, tooling and contractor time;
  • lost production during replacement;
  • damage to seats, rotors, housings or adjacent liners;
  • throughput or product-shape changes as the profile wears;
  • inventory and emergency freight;
  • inspection and disposal costs.

These values may not be available with the same confidence as part price and production. Keep measured values separate from estimates, state the assumptions, and avoid forcing every effect into one number when the evidence is weak.

Fill in the campaign comparison

What should a crusher wear parts supplier include in a quote?

Give both suppliers the same machine model, part position and part reference or drawing revision. Ask each supplier to state the fitted quantity, material specification and inspection scope. Have them itemise prices and charges to the same named delivery point, with spares on separate lines. If the part reference is unclear, use the guide to identifying crusher wear parts before requesting a quote.

Fill in both columns here or copy the table to a spreadsheet. Copy your entries before leaving this page. Give each figure its source and date, and label it as a quotation, a verified record or an estimate. Use numeric cells for amounts and tonnes, with the currency and units recorded separately. Mark missing inputs Pending and items outside the agreed cost boundary Excluded. In a cost field, enter zero only for a confirmed zero charge or credit.

FieldA · BaselineB · CandidateWhat to check
Set and quantityMachine, position, part references or drawing revisions, fitted quantity and contents per set. List spares separately.
Campaign and removal pointInstalled and removed dates or inspection cut-off. Label completed, in service or proposed. Record the removal criterion and any partial changes.
Currency and delivery basisRecord the named delivery point and treatment of freight, duty, insurance, handling and taxes. Compare in one currency and note the exchange rate, source and date if needed.
Cost boundaryUse the same boundary for both options. State whether you include downtime and scrap credits, and list any other exclusions.
Quoted set price and inclusionsRecord the line items, price per piece or per set, and included charges. Keep the quoted total as a reference. Sum only the cost rows specified in the net cost formula.
Part cost charged to the campaignAllocate the cost to the defined set and period, including any replacement pieces used. Document any value carried forward for unused or reusable parts.
Delivery costs outside the part costEnter only charges absent from the part cost used above.
Change-out labour, tools and servicesInclude attributable labour, lifting, tools or contractor charges on the same basis. Check for charges already included with the parts or in another row.
Attributable downtime impactRecord the hours, valuation basis and approval. Enter the estimated or verified downtime impact separately and count direct change-out costs only in their assigned row.
Other agreed campaign costsRecord any other agreed costs, such as inspection or disposal, that have not been included above.
Attributable scrap creditEnter a positive amount for the credit to subtract, with a receipt or a labelled estimate. Identify any credit already deducted from the part cost so it is counted once.
Subtotal from available costsIf an in-scope input is missing, subtotal the available amounts from the net cost formula. Subtract any available scrap credit that still needs to be deducted. Label any estimates in the subtotal and list the missing inputs.
Net campaign costAdd the agreed part, additional delivery, change-out, downtime and other costs once. Subtract the scrap credit still to be deducted. Mark the net cost pending if an included amount is missing.
Verified tonnes for the same periodUse metric tonnes at the same production measurement point, on the same feed or output basis. Attach the dated production record.
Net cost per verified tonneDivide net campaign cost by positive, verified tonnes from that campaign. Label estimates or results to date as provisional. With zero tonnes, mark the rate not applicable.
Forecast tonnes and projected cost per tonneEnter the forecast, its source and the matching projected net cost separately from verified results. Divide by the positive forecast tonnes and label the rate as projected.
Tonnes for B to match AReference rate aboveApply the break-even formula below. Mark the threshold provisional if it relies on an estimate or an active campaign.
Decision and information still neededNote scope differences, pending figures and any throughput or product-size requirement that must be met.

Net campaign cost per tonne = (part cost + additional delivery + change-out costs + agreed downtime impact + other agreed costs − scrap credit still to deduct) ÷ verified campaign tonnes

Use the formula for the agreed cost boundary. If a cost within that boundary is missing, show the subtotal from available costs, label any estimates and leave the net result pending. If you compare direct costs while downtime is still being estimated, apply that direct-cost basis to both options.

Calculate break-even tonnage

First divide A’s net campaign cost by A’s verified tonnage to get the reference cost per tonne. Use a comparable completed campaign for A, or explicitly label an interim reference.

B’s break-even tonnage = B’s net campaign cost ÷ A’s reference cost per tonne

This gives the tonnage at which both options cost the same per tonne. The formula requires positive net costs and positive verified tonnes for A. Leave the threshold pending if a required figure is missing. Keep A’s rate unrounded. For whole-tonne reporting, round the exact threshold down and add one tonne to find the first whole tonne at which B is strictly cheaper, provided B’s total cost stays as assumed.

Label the threshold as provisional when it uses a forecast cost or an interim baseline. If B needs another replacement or its cost changes as production rises, use the revised cost for that scope and recalculate. A forecast at the threshold implies an estimated tie and meets a target of matching A. A target of lower cost requires more tonnes at that same cost. Check how small changes in the inputs affect the result before using a narrow difference to choose a supplier.

Worked example in EUR

Illustrative assumptions only. A and B are hypothetical complete sets on the same cost basis. Delivery is additional to both part prices. The example includes assumed downtime and excludes other campaign costs and scrap credits. B’s processed tonnage is pending.

Cost or resultA · BaselineB · Candidate
Campaign status in the exampleAssumed completed campaignProposed trial
Part cost€800€1,200
Additional delivery€200€200
Change-out labour and tools€300€300
Assumed downtime impact€500€500
Net cost in the example€1,800€2,200
Campaign tonnes for comparison60,000 t assumedPending
Cost per tonne on that basis€0.030/tPending
Tonnes to match A’s cost per tonneReference campaign73,333.333… t

In the example, €2,200 ÷ (€1,800 ÷ 60,000 t) gives a break-even point of 73,333.333… t. At 73,334 whole tonnes, B would be just below A’s cost per tonne on these assumptions. If B were to reach 100,000 t at the same net cost, its projected cost would be €0.022/t. Verify B’s actual tonnage and costs before using the result to select an option.

Which assumptions change the result?

  • Delivered price. Check the included charges against the named delivery point. Count freight or handling once if it is already in the part cost.
  • Downtime. Keep the recorded hours and the value assigned to those hours identifiable. Show a comparable direct-cost result if the downtime impact is still unresolved.
  • Remaining value and scrap. Carry-forward value belongs to reusable parts. Scrap credit belongs to recovered material. Record each value once and state how it enters the campaign cost.
  • An active campaign. Report incurred cost and verified tonnes at the same cut-off, with the valuation of parts still in service stated. The final cost and tonnage remain pending.
  • Production. Compare the same throughput and product-size targets, and record feed or setting changes. A lower calculated cost per tonne supports a purchasing decision only when the relevant production and fit requirements are met.

Compare campaigns only after checking comparability

Fill in this table alongside the quotations. Mark a planned material change as a trial variable and flag missing evidence as Pending.

Comparison factorCampaign ACampaign BComparable?
Machine and chamber
Part geometry, mounting interfaces and usable wear profile
Feed and top size
Crusher setting and measured throughput
Target and measured product size
Installed quantity
Removal criterion and actual reason
Material specification
Inspection scope and measurement method
Abnormal events
Production data source

If several conditions changed, the records can still describe field performance, but they do not isolate the effect of material. The conclusion should say that clearly.

Use wear profile and failure mode with the numbers

Two parts can produce a similar cost per tonne and reach removal for different reasons. One may lose mass evenly; another may crack, flatten, loosen or damage a seat before its material is consumed.

Attach:

  • before-and-after photographs from consistent angles;
  • removed weights or controlled dimensions;
  • photographs of seating and retaining interfaces;
  • crack or insert-loss locations;
  • the reason for removal;
  • remaining usable profile, if the part was removed early.

For a hammer trial, record how many hammers were installed, their new and removed weights, whether hardfacing or inserts were present, and whether the complete set remained in service for the same period.

Crusher hammer beside a tape measure and steel rule
Overall workshop view of the hammer and the measuring setup. Photograph the whole part so the measuring points can be located.
Close-up of a digital caliper beside the hammer mounting hole
Caliper close-up at the mounting hole. Record the part reference and measuring points with the reading.

Read field records as evidence, not universal promises

The published hammer records include customer-supplied worksheets and correspondence with identifying details removed. The disclosed tonnage, wear rate and cost figures belong to those operating records. They should not be presented as guaranteed results for another crusher or material route.

The Romanian limestone worksheet covers four hammer campaigns. Its public cost figures are rounded component costs. A full comparison needs itemised cost inputs, downtime records and comparable operating conditions. Romanian crusher hammer field record.

The transferable value is the method: identify the set, define the campaign, measure consumption, verify production, record changes and calculate on a consistent cost basis.

Build the next trial around a decision rule

Before ordering a trial set, agree what success means. It may be lower component cost per tonne, reduced breakage risk, a longer planned change interval, more stable throughput or fewer emergency replacements. Record the baseline using the same method that will be applied to the trial.

Paste a summary of the worksheet into the “Which part do you need?” field. Include the part references, what each offer covers, the costs you included, the campaign dates and verified tonnes, and any estimated or missing inputs. Include cost per tonne and break-even tonnage when you can calculate them. Open “Company and part details (optional)” to select the equipment category. Attach a drawing or wear photo if it helps identify the parts. Send your quote comparison for review.

Read this guide in Spanish.

FAQ

What is the simplest crusher wear cost-per-tonne formula?

Divide the delivered component cost consumed during the campaign by the verified tonnes processed in the same campaign. Keep currency, freight basis and component scope consistent.

How is mass wear rate calculated?

Sum the new-to-removed mass loss for the measured parts, convert kilograms to grams, and divide by the verified processed tonnes. State whether all installed parts were measured.

Can two campaigns be compared if feed conditions changed?

They can be reviewed, but the operating change must be recorded and the result should not be treated as a controlled material comparison. Feed, setting, throughput and abnormal events can materially affect wear.

Can I compare a delivered quote with an ex-works quote?

Bring both offers to the same named delivery point and count each verified charge once. If an in-scope delivery charge is missing, subtotal the available costs, label any estimates and leave the full cost-per-tonne comparison pending.

How many tonnes does a candidate set need to break even?

Divide the candidate set's positive net campaign cost by the unrounded, positive baseline cost per verified tonne. Use the same cost scope for both sets. Label the threshold as provisional when it relies on estimated costs or an interim baseline.

ZC

Crusher wear parts, alloy selection and foundry process review

Company casting records date to 1992

From article to application

Need to apply this to your machine?

Send the machine model, operating conditions and current wear pattern. An engineer will help translate the article into a practical part choice.

Ask an Engineer About This Topic

Include photos or an OEM reference for a more specific answer.

Looking for crusher liners, mill liners or other wear parts?

Browse Products →